Google Analytics plays mobile catch up…… and still manages to come last!

Google Analytics plays mobile catch up

Google Analytics plays mobile catch up

For a company with such a public focus on mobile browsing Google has repeatedly failed to cater for anything mobile in their analytics product. Indeed, independent comparisons earlier this year showed that Google Analytics only tracked 12% of the mobile page views to a website that Bango Analytics identified (see http://www.brysonmeunier.com/mobile-analytics-with-google-analytics for details). So after much waiting and unknown quantities of inaccurate analytics reports later, Google announced a new version of Google Analytics and this time the long list of features includes [sound of fanfare] “mobile tracking”. Among a big list of new features on their website there is a whole, but small, paragraph dedicated to mobile. Read more »

It was THE mobile web party

Last night it seemed that Movida in London was the place to be for anyone in the mobile industry. As Bango celebrated 10 years of the mobile web, it was great to see so many industry peers gathering to celebrate such an important milestone for the mobile industry.Bango 10 years mobile web party

There was a great buzz, with people from all parts of the mobile and entertainment industry, including mobile operators, content providers, press and Bango’s partners. It was an evening of great fun and excitement.

Bango has been here since the beginning of the mobile web revolution, initially with the idea of Bango numbers and now with their very successful mobile payment and analytics products, counting companies such as MTV, Turner Broadcasting Inc and Dada among its customers.

So as the evening drew to a close and everyone went home, the Bango folks headed back home on their coach to Cambridge, with a big smile in their faces…..and probably followed by some sore heads earlier this morning!

How important are Smartphones and which matters most?

Bango provides the best mobile payment experience on smartphones

Smartphones account for 28% of all handsets in the US according to NPD Group

The research firm NPD Group have just announced a new survey that shows smartphone sales in the USA grew by 47% in Q2 and accounted for 28% of all handset sales. That’s a number big enough to make anyone selling to mobile take note – it’s more than a quarter of all your customers. And it’s not all Apple iPhones either – the report goes on to reveal that 35% of handsets shipped with keyboards rather than touch screens, pointing to Blackberry, Google Android and Windows Mobile phones. Samsung and LG are highlighted as top selling manufacturers in the report.

Interestingly, feature phones made up a massive 72% of phone sales during Q2. These devices may be more traditional in design but they deliver a great web browsing experience and many of the features found in the more expensive smartphones, such as Wifi and GPS. So while Apple is doing a great job building excitement and consumer demand, many of those consumers are simply getting the features they need through their favorite phone manufacturer. You can read more about this report at Fiercewireless.com.

The other interesting report this week came from Fortune magazine, which announced that Research in Motion, the manufacturer of the Blackberry phone, is the world’s fastest growing company. To put that into perspective, Apple appear way down at position 39 and Google only make it to position 68. The full list can be seen here. This clearly shows that Blackberry is the most important smartphone to be targeting.

By using Bango Payment you can be confident you are already selling the most to Blackberry customers and giving them the best possible payment experience. You also have the advantage over other mobile billing solutions that don’t work on Blackberry – they either fail completely or present far more complex payment screens that lose sales. Blackberry phones connect to the internet via servers owned by Research in Motion, this blocks important identification information and prevents standard operator billing from working. The same happens when a smartphone or feature phone connects over Wifi – again identification information is not available which prevents most solutions from offering operator billing. All our mobile payment products use Bango Identifier technology to identify customers and ensure they get the same simple operator billing experience. It works on Blackberry’s connected via RIM servers and on smartphones or feature phones connected over Wifi.

Wi-Fi – the reason you are losing 20% of your sales today

Recent reports clearly show a rapid increase in mobile phones browsing using Wi-Fi – according to recent Bango research over 20% of your customers are now connecting via Wi-Fi (see Bango Wi-Fi stats). Millennial Media also reported 22% Wi-Fi use in the USA as part of their June U.S Scorecard for Mobile Advertising Reach and Targeting (SMART) report (see  Millenial Media report).

Bango goes on to predict that over a third of all mobile customers will use Wi-Fi by 2010. Combine this with the increased growth in smartphone sales with 38.1 million units sold worldwide in the first quarter of 2009, and it represents a very large percentage of your customers. Using Wi-Fi makes browsing your store fast, easy and cost effective, but it also introduces significant challenges which, if not addressed, will lose 20% of your sales.

Wi-Fi operator billing experience
Wi-Fi operator billing experience

I think we all agree that operator billing delivers the highest number of successful sales – the ability that consumers have to simply click and pay using their mobile phone bill makes those impulse purchases so fast and simple. It would be great if they had all the speed and convenience of operator billing combined with the benefits of Wi-Fi. But unfortunately since your customer is not connected using an authenticated operator connection, that familiar operator billing payment experience cannot be offered. Even your most loyal customers become total strangers when they connect using Wi-Fi, which means they are no longer able to just click and pay.

To date many mobile billing solutions simply give up, leaving customers unable to pay, while others just show an error when they try. A few mobile payment solutions try to overcome this by providing the unknown customer with an alternate way to pay. Some offer credit card which will give you a few extra sales, but it will be significantly less than the 20% you would have captured if the familiar operator billing was available. There are one or two hand built remedies, requiring a payment confirmation code in a text message to be memorized and entered back in the browser to complete the payment. Even with the best keyboards and touch screens these alternative billing experiences will deliver lower payment success.

To make things trickier, customers often change their network connection. For example, while on the move they will browse using their operator network – payments will be quick and simple using familiar operator billing. When they get to work, back home or to their local coffee shop their phone will connect via a Wi-Fi hotspot. When they go to buy more from your store they will get blocked or presented with a different, inferior payment alternative. So even though they are trying to buy from the same site, your store, they will be presented with very inconsistent payment experiences based on their connection.

So as well as losing 20% of sales due to Wi-Fi, you are also likely to lose customers as they get confused and fail to buy what they want. This might also mean an increase in the number of customers contacting your service team, as they can’t simply pay.

The way to capture this 20% of Wi-Fi customers is quite simple, it is crucial that the customer always gets exactly the same operator billing experience, independent of their network connection or phone – it must just work as they expect, even over Wi-Fi. Being able to consistently click to pay on the mobile phone bill also increases customer satisfaction, transaction speed and repeat business.

Bango is the only company to deliver a consistent payment experience across all phones and connections as part of the new Bango Payment product. There isn’t anything else you can do today, with no outlay, to boost your revenue by 20%.

Latest Wifi vs MNO stats show continued fast growth in Wifi use

Bango has just made available the latest data showing the share of web access from mobiles that comes through Wifi vs Mobile Operator networks.

To download the full stats click on the link below:

Bango WiFi Market Data 2 Q09

The share has grown to about 20% for mobile focussed sites and 30% overall.

There is also data to show how many users use Wifi only, Operator Only or both – in the same month.

17%, 69% and 14% respectively. Very interesting!

Currently, Bango Payment services can only do operator billing on the users coming through operator connections. Content providers would love to gain the speed and high conversion rates of operator billing when users come in through Wifi – many of them are the highest spenders…..

Watch this space!

Warning – WiFi may cause Blindness!

A senior Nokia executive at a recent Mobile 2.0 conference told me that some of their biggest mobile operator customers were concerned that the newest Nokia phones (N97, 5800) will switch automatically to WiFi if they detect a network.

The number of mobile users connecting through WiFi has risen sharply in recent months

The number of mobile users connecting through WiFi has risen sharply in recent months

 Some operators like the idea of users on “all you can eat” mobile web tariffs using WiFi – heavy users will not saturate the network. Mobile users like the typical speed increase they get – especially when in the home or office.

However, in the era of the intelligent mobile web, operators now worry about losing the connection with the user – they can’t see where the users are going, they can’t provide added value services, potentially they can’t protect the user from visiting the wrong web sites!

The amount of traffic coming from mobile phones connecting through WiFi has risen sharply in recent months. This seems to have been driven by the popularity of smart phones like the N95, Blackberries, WinMo devices and iPhones – all of which easily connect via WiFi. This is why it’s now so important to track which network mobile users are using – to optimize payment experience and for analytics.

The difficulty this presents to mobile operators is that they can’t see this traffic – because it bypasses their networks. When you access your operator home page via WiFi, the current experience on most networks is that you are turned away – you can’t access your account or buy from the portal.

The GSMA is sponsoring a survey about user habits and advertising – but I fear this will ignore the 33% of WiFi traffic – despite the fact that this is probably from the most active, leading edge users.

WiFi is a great opportunity for mobile operators and content providers, but they need the technology that will enable them to see their WiFi traffic so they can deliver a friendly mobile payment experience to their users as they swap between connections.

To remain “blind” to this trend in customer behavior – or worse still to actively resist it – is, I believe, wrong-headed. Fortunately, based on my experience, WiFi does not cause blindness – it merely exposes blindness to new revenue opportunities through some “old school” thinking.

Whatever you do, don’t lose sight of the rewards that WiFi can deliver if you are either a content provider or a mobile operator, and the value that partners like Bango add when it comes to capturing revenue from this growing segment of your customer base.

BLOOM-ing marvellous learning opportunities on mobile

When it comes to mobile learning, no one knows more about this than BLOOM, the Bite-sized Learning Opportunities on Mobiles project headed up by Tribal with input and support from Bango.

Bite-sized Learning Opportunities on Mobile

Bite-sized Learning Opportunities on Mobile


Mobile learning succeeds because its palm-sized micro-courses can fit more readily into a busy work schedule,” said Geoff Stead, Tribal’s mobile learning expert.  “It’s already proving popular with taxi drivers and train drivers who don’t sit in front of a desk and have easy access to e-learning or face to face training.”

Mobile learning visionaries gathered together this week to share their experiences, with Mike Short, O2’s vice president of Technology on hand to lend his support for this innovative project.

Mobile learning is not new.  Two projects - the international award winning Learning2Go mobile learning projects in Wolverhampton schools and MoLENet, the £12m government funded mobile initiative for adult learners - have already proved the concept.  The next task is to roll this out to a wider audience and that’s where BLOOM comes in.

“It makes so much sense to use the mobile internet to deliver bite-size training to a very mobile workforce,” said Ray Anderson, CEO of Bango.  “M-learning is fun and accessible to everyone – its so much more accessible to people who would previously been put-off by a classroom training situation or reading through pages and pages of text.”

Tribal has many different learning resources for mobile and is keen to roll these out into different communities as well as hear from people of their specific training needs.  Learn more at http://www.m-learning.org/

Need help getting valuable insight into mobile advertising?

SMART report gives you insight into mobile advertising

SMART report gives you insight into mobile advertising

It’s always great to get your hands on free mobile web industry stats, isn’t it? So I was pleased to find a new monthly report compiled by Millennial Media with a whole range of mobile advertising data.

It’s the first report I’ve seen of its kind and unlike the Admob stats, it seems more representative of the general market rather than Admob’s bias towards the iPhone mobile advertising market which has developed because it provides a specific service for advertisers who want to target iPhone users.

SMART which stands for Scorecard for Mobile Advertising Reach and Targeting is a monthly report providing a comprehensive view of the US mobile advertising market and device trends.  The report details Millennial Media’s findings based on actual campaigns and additional statistics from independent analysts.

The reports which are also targeted at brand advertisers provide data and insights to drive decisions on mobile advertising campaign spend and includes campaign interactions, cost per engagement, key handset and carrier data plus much more.

One of the most insightful reports was the comparison of intent to purchase from mobile verses online campaigns.  It shows the power of mobile campaigns particularly among 18-24 year olds whose intent to purchase was nine times higher on mobile than online.

It’s definitely worth a look – download the latest copy from the Millennial Media website.

Payment experience on the Nokia Ovi store – where’s operator billing?

Nokia's Ovi content store

Nokia's Ovi content store

Like many, we eagerly awaited the new Nokia Ovi store to see what was available and how easy it was to buy paid-for apps.

The store did seem to be packed with free apps, mostly in the entertainment genre which is not surprising given Nokia’s penetration of the mass market. Business Week commented this week that there are few business apps but not doubt this will rapidly change developers flock to this new platform.

We liked the Flipsilent app that make the phone silent when you placed it face down. Neat! I’d recommend a browse, there’s some great content there.

Why do I have to login before I can buy content?

Why do I have to login to buy content?

So what was the payment experience? Well, there’s no doubt that this is an area which Nokia will rapidly improve but it’s not up to scratch. We accessed the Ovi store on a Nokia N95 in the UK on the Vodafone network.

I want to buy the Handy Converter app for £6.00, so how do I pay? Can I just click to confirm a Payforit Transaction? Er, No. There’s no quick, single click payment experience as all Bango powered sites have in the UK, USA, Germany, etc.

First I need to log into the Ovi store. Why put barriers in the way of people paying for your content? Then I get sent back to the app page to confirm again that I want to buy.

Paying with my credit/debit card

Paying with my credit/debit card

Then I enter my credit card details to pay, choosing between Visa, DinersClub and American Express . But what about my Mastercard – the most popular card type. I gave up at that point. Disappointing, because the Nokia price is 20% less than almost anywhere else.

As Nokia has already commented, conversion rates are much higher when you provide single click on-bill so we eagerly await this.

Here’s what George Linardos, Nokia’s VP of product management said:

“When we start locally with credit card billing and then we move to operator billing, we see a 70 percent lift in sales literally over night.”

Paying on the phone bill needs to be a seamless, mobile web experience where the user is automatically recognized and there’s no need to send a text message to put a charge on the phone bill.  That’s what Bango does for millions of mobile content purchases every month.

Share add to del.icio.us Add to Blinkslist add to furl Digg it add to ma.gnolia Stumble It! add to simpy seed the vine TailRank post to facebook

Could the Apple App Store overtake the Crazy Frog?

The Crazy Frog kick-started the mobile content industry in 2004

The Crazy Frog kick-started the mobile content industry in 2004

The Crazy Frog was the mass market phenomenon that launched ringtones into the mass market in 2004.  Within two years, it is estimated that it generated sales in excess of $400 million dollars for Jamba (which became part of Verisign and ultimately Fox) and other affiliates - by direct sale of a single ringtone.

Crazy Frog sales were  £40 million in the UK alone in the first year  making up 40% of UK ringtone sales. It was then used by Jamba/Jamster to encourage subscriptions to other ringtone services.   Up to 50 million users worldwide (up to 6 million in the UK alone) downloaded one or more Crazy Frog variants within two years to their phones.

The Crazy Frog spawned a range of musical hits, including a remix Axel F which remained in the European music charts for months in 2005, not to mention the plush toy spinoffs

More importantly, extensive reporting of the Crazy Frog across mainstream media such as tabloid newspapers, mainstream TV news and even the broadsheets brought the  idea of ringtones to the mass market – beyond its teen appeal.  When Bango floated on the UK stock market in mid 2005, a year of Crazy Frog success  made the idea of mobile content more plausible to investors and helped our successful float.

The Apple App Store seems to be on the same track.  Although Apple is very secretive, the App Store may be managing to achieve similar sales growth to the Crazy Frog over its first year or so. While Apple’s sales are a tiny part of the overall multi-billion dollar mobile app and content market, since it is restricted to 20 million or so iPhones/iTouches it has captured the imagination of  journalists and the  technorati.  It has re-invigorated interest in app stores among other phone makers and even breathed some life into operator portals.

While handset specific app stores may in reality prove to be just a passing fad that can be surfed as progress continues towards a web centric model, one could level the same charge against “The Annoying Thing”.  

The recent furore over Apple selling a “shake the baby to death”  application echoes the problem the Crazy Frog had with its exposed genitalia,  just the sort of PR to help get mainstream attention. 

A quick Google search will also demonstrate that the sense of humour of iPhone users are not much different from the mobile phone users of 2005!

I expect we will look back in 2-3 years time and realise that despite all the other activities from operators, brands and music companies it was the Apple App store – by then still a small part of the overall market – that gave the content industry the boost into the real world that it needed back in 2009.